dishvote.
Sign in

Dish ranking

Best pizzas in New York

8 pizzas from 4 restaurants, ranked by 102 recorded votes.

Every pizzeria has one pie that shows what the oven can do. These are the pizzas diners keep voting to the top.

In New York the highest recorded total belongs to Margherita Pizza at Grimaldi's Pizzeria, with 32 votes. Every row below links to the dish page, where you can see the other dishes at that restaurant and add your own vote.

Recorded totals include starter data and votes from members and guests. They are not counts of verified diners or star ratings. How rankings work

The ranking

  1. 1Margherita PizzaGrimaldi's Pizzeria32 votes
  2. 2Pepperoni PizzaGrimaldi's Pizzeria23 votes
  3. 3CalzoneGrimaldi's Pizzeria17 votes
  4. 4White PizzaGrimaldi's Pizzeria14 votes
  5. 5Mushroom PizzaGrimaldi's Pizzeria9 votes
  6. 6Fresh Basil PizzaDi Fara Pizza5 votes
  7. 7Margherita PizzaLulla NYCA traditional Neapolitan pizza with San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil. Cooked in a wood-fired oven.1 votes
  8. 8Pizza Salsiccia e FriarielliIl CortileNeapolitan-style pizza with crumbled Italian sausage, sautéed bitter greens, mozzarella, and a touch of chili.1 votes

How to order pizzas well

  • Order the margherita first at a new place, nothing hides behind three ingredients.
  • Ask what style the oven is set up for: Neapolitan, New York, deep dish or Roman al taglio.
  • Split a plain pie and a speciality pie so you can compare crust and toppings.

Pizzas in New York: common questions

What are the best pizzas in New York?
The highest recorded total is for Margherita Pizza at Grimaldi's Pizzeria first, with 32 votes. The full ranking above covers 8 pizzas across 4 New York restaurants and updates as recorded totals change.
How is this New York ranking decided?
Dishes are ordered by recorded totals, including starter data, member votes and guest votes. This is not a star rating or a survey of verified diners.
Can I add a pizza that is missing?
Yes. Open the restaurant page, add the dish, and it enters this ranking once it is approved and matches this category.

Same dish, other cities

All restaurants in New York