Dish ranking
Best seafood dishes in New York
26 seafood dishes from 14 restaurants, ranked by 277 recorded votes.
Seafood is the category where location matters most, the best plate is the one landed nearby that morning.
In New York the highest recorded total belongs to Barely Cooked Salmon at Le Bernardin, with 50 votes. Every row below links to the dish page, where you can see the other dishes at that restaurant and add your own vote.
Recorded totals include starter data and votes from members and guests. They are not counts of verified diners or star ratings. How rankings work
The ranking
- 1Barely Cooked SalmonLe Bernardin50 votes
- 2Tuna MeltEisenberg's Sandwich Shop49 votes
- 3Oysters and PearlsPer Se45 votes
- 4Salmon CornetsPer Se34 votes
- 5Toro TunaMasa21 votes
- 6TunaLe Bernardin19 votes
- 7Butter Poached LobsterPer Se16 votes
- 8Yellowfin TunaDaniel9 votes
- 9Baked ClamsRao's8 votes
- 10LobsterLe Bernardin7 votes
- 11CatfishSylvia's Restaurant5 votes
- 12Lobster Thermidor1803 NYCClassic whole lobster baked in a rich, creamy brandy sauce with mushrooms, then topped with Gruyere cheese and broiled until golden brown.3 votes
- 13Snow CrabMasa3 votes
- 14Ackee & Saltfish CroquettesTatiana by Kwame OnwuachiCrispy croquettes filled with the classic Jamaican ackee and saltfish, served with a spicy scotch bonnet aioli.2 votes
- 15Pan-Seared Scallops with Saffron RisottoCrown ShyPerfectly seared diver scallops nestled atop a creamy saffron-infused risotto, garnished with fresh herbs.2 votes
- 16Pan-Seared Scallops with Saffron Risotto1803 NYCPerfectly seared scallops atop creamy saffron-infused Arborio rice, garnished with fresh parsley and a drizzle of lemon-infused olive oil.2 votes
- 17New Orleans BBQ Shrimp1803 NYCJumbo shrimp sautéed in a spicy, buttery Worcestershire sauce, served with crusty French bread for dipping. A true taste of the Bayou.1 votes
- 18Oysters Rockefeller1803 NYCFreshly shucked oysters baked with a rich topping of herbs, breadcrumbs, and Pernod, offering a decadent oceanic experience.1 votes
- 19Aegean Shrimp SaganakiMezze on the RiverSucculent shrimp baked in a rich tomato sauce with ouzo, herbs, and crumbly feta cheese, served with crusty bread.0 votes
- 20Charred Octopus with 'Nduja VinaigretteCrown ShyTender grilled octopus, potato confit, and a vibrant vinaigrette made with spicy 'nduja sausage.0 votes
- 21Manhatta Lobster ThermidorManhattaClassic lobster thermidor with a modern twist, featuring a creamy cognac sauce, wild mushrooms, and a crispy herb crust.0 votes
- 22Mediterranean Sea BassMezze on the RiverPan-seared sea bass fillet with a lemon-herb dressing, accompanied by roasted seasonal vegetables and a sprinkle of toasted almonds.0 votes
- 23Pan-Seared Halibut with AsparagusManhattaFlaky pan-seared halibut, served with roasted asparagus, fingerling potatoes, and a vibrant green goddess sauce.0 votes
- 24Pan-Seared ScallopsFrevoPerfectly seared scallops with a delicate cauliflower puree, crispy capers, and a brown butter vinaigrette.0 votes
- 25Seared Scallops with Saffron RisottoManhattaPan-seared jumbo scallops atop creamy saffron risotto, finished with snap peas and a lemon-butter emulsion.0 votes
- 26Seared Scallops with Sweet Corn RisottoWatermarkPan-seared, plump scallops served atop creamy sweet corn risotto, finished with a drizzle of basil oil.0 votes
How to order seafood dishes well
- Ask what came in today; a good kitchen will happily tell you.
- Whole fish is usually better value and better cooked than a portioned fillet.
- Raw plates, oysters, ceviche, crudo, reveal freshness immediately.
Seafood dishes in New York: common questions
- What are the best seafood dishes in New York?
- The highest recorded total is for Barely Cooked Salmon at Le Bernardin first, with 50 votes. The full ranking above covers 26 seafood dishes across 14 New York restaurants and updates as recorded totals change.
- How is this New York ranking decided?
- Dishes are ordered by recorded totals, including starter data, member votes and guest votes. This is not a star rating or a survey of verified diners.
- Can I add a seafood dish that is missing?
- Yes. Open the restaurant page, add the dish, and it enters this ranking once it is approved and matches this category.